TOGY talks to Ranji Dua, managing partner at Dua Associates, about policies holding together the oil and gas industry in India, handling disputes in the exploration and production sector and necessary improvements to the country’s infrastructure. Dua Associates has been offering legal advice to local and international players in the energy industry since the 1980s.
What is your analysis of the new HELP policy?
It is still evolving. For example, open acreages have been in the pipeline for some time. The person who comes with the proposal should be given some security that the proposal as formulated will remain confidential for some time and some other rights. It is still not clear how it will be worked out, if it will be open bidding, or whether the opportunity will be given to the person who made the proposal. Also, I believe nothing has happened in terms of awarding blocks for at least two years. There are issues to be sorted out.
Now whoever is interested can come. The state invites interest and anyone can make a bid. However, just because someone could make a better bid does not mean it will automatically attract investors. The key is data. Why would anybody come forward with a proposal to benefit someone else? You want the security that you will get what you want. It will have to be seen how it works in practice.
Where does India stand now in terms of a dispute resolution mechanism in E&P?
We do a lot of arbitration in oil and gas, and we have seen that the outside expert committee sometimes functions, but sometimes cannot resolve the dispute. These arbitrations need to be dealt with very quickly. They tend to last far too long, which becomes a huge burden on the entire industry as well as the contractor.
There is an overall need to review government litigation. What really needs to be looked over are the outstanding disputes that are under resolution and how to expedite resolving them. There are so many things that could be done to make the process easier and faster.
There are people who are knowledgeable about the oil and gas world. Appointing such people as arbitrators or assessors would contribute to quicker resolution because some of these issues are extremely technical. It would be very hard to explain to an ordinary lawyer about decommissioning, for example. It makes all the difference to have someone who understands the issues to begin with. You cannot advise and decide if you do not know.
In 2006, the McDermott arbitration [disputes between McDermott International and Burn Standard decided by the Supreme Court on May 12, 2006] reached its final conclusion in the Supreme Court, after something like 20 years. If the government is anxious to resolve disputes, I think it can be done.
How do you assess the upstream industry in India?
India is the only country that is still investing substantial amounts in the oil and gas industry. In the case of ONGC Videsh, they are going to spend USD 12 billion buying up tenements and investing in oil. In other places, with the oil prices falling below USD 40 per barrel, investments are being held back and even abandoned, which will ultimately prove very costly for the international oil and gas industry.
If the oil price goes up, India will be at the forefront. The country is sure of its own demand and has to meet it; we have to keep investing. If we do not invest, our long term growth will be severely impacted.
I think India would keep investing as long as the price remains above USD 20 per barrel. If it falls below that, there may arise a question of investing. However, it would be mostly from the government’s side. Private players are in turmoil today and do not have any strategic imperatives to invest.
Does India need to improve its infrastructure for these investments to yield?
Infrastructure is a very critical area. According to the National Highways Authority, India has the world’s largest network of roadworks underway. Rail transport in India is huge as well; I think it is the world’s largest network and it is the world’s largest employer. There is going to be huge growth here. Additionally, we have never used our internal river waters system for transportation, but are now starting with the opportunity.
American involvement in these areas will be very interesting to watch. The American and Indian governments now appear to have a good understanding of each other. Until now, the private sectors have been working together. However, today America and India are strategically aligned and are now also economically aligned.
There is also the Japan-USA-India trialogue and strategic alignment. We are trying to get into trade blocks as well. India is putting pressure on America to open up its visa procedures and labour market if we commit to opening up ours. You need a labour market in addition to a product market. Also, if you are opening markets, you need to believe in open markets – everything is interlinked, such as wages, costs and manufacturing.
We have to wait and see. This could all change depending on who becomes the next president. We see a lot of interest in India.
TOGY talks to Sylvain Itté, French Ambassador to Angola, about the strong economic and cultural ties between the two countries,… Read More
TOGY talks to Li Patrik, director of energy, environment, infrastructure at the China-Britain Business Council (CBBC), about the difficulties of… Read More
TOGY talks to Río Negro province Secretary of Hydrocarbons Sebastian Caldiero about policies implemented by the provincial government to manage… Read More
TOGY talks to Heba Filobbos, area manager of the Northern Gulf for Halliburton, about the company’s experience working as an… Read More
TOGY talks to Christopher Gunson, partner at Amereller, about the oil and gas industry in the UAE and the surrounding… Read More
TOGY talks to Graeme Taylor, Vice President for Angola at Halliburton, about forecasted stabilisation, onshore potential and the qualities required… Read More
This website uses cookies.